Preservation and Conservation

Photo & Video Sharing by SmugMug
White-tailed Deer


On Tuesday, March 3rd, 2009 President Obama overturned legislation enacted at the end of the Bush Administration that weakened the Endangered Species Act. Bush's legislation allowed government agencies to launch projects without consulting government scientists if they deemed that those projects would cause no harm to endangered species. I completely agree with what Obama did. Government agencies are not qualified to say what projects might harm endangered species, and scientists, at least in principle, ought to be able to provide more guidance for what may or may not be harmful to endangered species

Three Lakes WMA
Red-cockaded Woodpecker
A threatened species due to habitat loss
But what I found interesting was the following quote from President Obama: "Throughout our history, there's been a tension between those who've sought to conserve our natural resources for the benefit of future generations and those who have sought to profit from these resources."  That's a very interesting way to frame the tension.  On the one hand, some want to conserve natural resources, while others desire to use those resources for profit.

Hal Scott Preserve
Bachman's Sparrow
A threatened species due to habitat loss
I think that oversimplifies matters significantly. Historically, if I may offer a less oversimplified opinion, the tension was between three groups, which we may call industrialists,conservationists and preservationists. Industrialists often sought to use natural resources for production, progress and profit.  Conservationists like Gifford Pinchot typically opposed the efforts of industrialists; they believed that we can and should benefit from our natural resources, but future generations will be unable to do so if we do not act responsibly. They were about conserving the worlds resources so tht they would be sustainable for long-term commercial use. Preservationists were a bit more extreme. John Muir, for instance, saw the world a kind of divine temple that should be hallowed and left as unchanged as possible.  Nature should be protected from human intervention.  He saw our national parks as having transcendent spiritual qualities.

Mead Gardens
Red-headed Woodpecker
A threatened species due to habitat loss
For myself, I suspect I'm a conservationist influenced by preservationist theology.  I agree with Pinchot that we should be concerned about sustainable use of resources so that our natural resources are not depleted.  However, I do sorely wish I could have seen Sierra Park Valley and Yosemite as Muir had seen them--I wish he had succeeded in preserving them.  Muir was right in a very profound sense that evangelicals often forget--this world is God's temple. It's the showcase of God's glory. However, God placed us in this world to care for it, tend to it, and cultivate it.  It's not to be left alone. The balance between cultivating the world we live in and preserving its beauty and diversity as God's temple is difficult, but it's one we should seek after, and it's one that oversimplified soundbites will never help us achieve.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

More Ready than You Realize

Image
Evangelism as Dance in the Postmodern Matrix Brian D. McLaren I liked this book a whole lot more than I expected to. It offers a very engaging challenge to those who would want to package evangelism into diagnostic questions, canned illustrations or five point outlines. He likens it to a dance. It "begins with something beyond yourself," and "over time, your whol life begins to harmonize to the song. It's rhythm awakens you; its tempo moves you, so you resonate with its tone and flow with its melody. The lyric gradually convinces you that the entire world is meant to share in this song with its message, its joy, its dance" (pp. 15-6). McLaren understands that it is the gospel itself, and the transformation that occurs in us by God's Spirit that motivates our engagement with unbelievers. And he undestands that the hope of the gospel is more than just the conversion of the sinner--the entire cosmos (not the sum total of all people in the world) is suppo...
Read more

Regnum Caelorum

Image
Patterns of Millennial Thought in Early Christianity, 2nd Edition C. E. Hill Welcome to my theological blog page. The title Regnum Caelorum , meaning "kingdom of heaven," is taken from an excellent book written by one of my professors about the history and development of millennial thought in the early church. Hill's argument is that, despite popular opinion, there were many in the early church (particularly from the late first to third centuries) that were not "chiliasts" (or premillennialists by today's terminology). These non-chiliasts can be identified because they believed in a heavenly afterlife, as opposed to their chiliast bretheren, all of which believed they would rest in Hades after death. In fact, reading his book makes one believe that chiliasm was a development in early Christianity around the middle of the second century. I highly recommend it to those interested in the history of eschatology in the early church. For an overview of Hill...
Read more

Incarnational Ministry

Image
I was having lunch with other missionaries on a mission compound in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. I was enjoying getting to know these men and women that had given their lives in the service of the gospel in one of the poorest countries in the world. I was there with my friend Elias, and we were sharing with another missionary about the disabilities conference we were putting on for the churches in Addis. Joni Erickson Tada had come with us to Ethiopia to help us make the church aware of the need to reach out and care for those with disabilities among them. My role in the conference was to be a photographer and instructor on how the Bible calls us to serve “the least of these” among us. I told my new friend, “The conference is designed to equip churches with what they need to be able to serve the disabled all around them.” The missionary’s response was quite surprising: “Well, it’s all well and good to care for the poor and disabled, but that’s not the ministry of the church. The mini...
Read more